Find Makers Near You

How much of your money stays local when you buy from a local furniture maker

Research compiled by the American Independent Business Alliance, averaging a series of studies by the firm Civic Economics, found that 52.9 percent of each dollar spent at a local independent business recirculates locally, against 13.6 percent at a chain. That is roughly a four-to-one difference. Commissioning furniture from an independent maker sits at the strong end of that range, because there is no imported inventory in the transaction: the money goes to a person's labor, to materials, and to a shop that is physically in your area.

Reviewed

How the multiplier works

The local multiplier is not a slogan, it is an accounting exercise with three components.

Component What it means Furniture example
Direct What the business itself spends locally to operate The maker's shop rent, utilities, insurance, equipment, and their own pay
Indirect What the business spends at other local businesses The local lumberyard, the hardware supplier, the finishing supplier, the local accountant
Induced What the owner and employees spend of their income locally Groceries, rent, school fees, restaurants, everything else

The difference between an independent and a chain is mostly in the direct and indirect layers. A chain's inventory is bought centrally, its accounting is done at headquarters, its profit leaves the region, and its marketing is national. An independent buys locally out of necessity.

Why a commission is a strong case

Not all "local" purchases are equal, and this distinction is worth making because it is honest.

A local furniture store that sells imported furniture recirculates its margin locally. That is real, and it is better than a chain, but the largest part of what you paid, the cost of the goods, leaves immediately.

A local furniture maker is a different transaction. There is no cost of goods sold in the retail sense. What you are buying is:

  • Labor, which is the largest line, and it belongs to someone who lives near you
  • Materials, frequently bought from a regional lumber supplier
  • Shop overhead, which is local rent, local utilities, local insurance
  • Finish, hardware, and consumables, some regional and some not

Even where the hardware comes from overseas, the labor component, which is typically the majority of a commission, is unambiguously local. That is the structural reason commissioning scores well on this measure, and it is a stronger claim than "shop local" in the abstract.

What that looks like on a real purchase

Take a $2,500 commission, roughly the median on Maker Marketplace. Under the averaged figure above, about $1,320 would be expected to recirculate locally, against about $340 on an equivalent chain purchase. A difference of roughly $980 on a single piece.

Treat that as an illustration of the ratio rather than a measurement of your specific town. The point is the order of magnitude, not the decimal.

The limits of this research, stated plainly

Anyone citing these numbers should know what they are.

  • The studies are retail studies. Civic Economics examined independent retailers, restaurants, and similar businesses. Custom furniture making was not the subject. The direction of the finding applies well to commissioning; the exact percentage was not measured on this category.
  • They were commissioned by organizations that advocate for local business. That does not make them wrong, and the methodology is standard regional input-output analysis, but it is a relevant disclosure.
  • The figures are averages across markets. A market with a deep local supply chain scores higher. One where everything is trucked in scores lower.
  • "Local" is defined by study area, usually a city or county. Your definition may differ.
  • Multiplier analysis measures circulation, not welfare. It tells you where money goes, not whether the community is better off in every respect.

None of that undoes the finding. Independent businesses recirculate substantially more than chains, consistently, across many markets. It does mean the honest version of the claim is "roughly four times as much on average," not "exactly 52.9 percent of your table."

The arguments that are not about money

Worth naming, because they are often the real reason people buy locally and they do not show up in a multiplier study.

  • You can visit the shop. Seeing the wood before it is cut changes what you order.
  • You can be repaired. A maker twenty minutes away will fix a joint in year twelve. A container ship will not.
  • The piece can fit. Local makers measure your room. This is the actual reason most commissions happen.
  • Skills stay in the area. Trades survive where there is demand for them. There is no abstract way to preserve a craft; someone has to buy the work.

Sources

Maker MarketPlace Background

Frequently asked questions

Research compiled by the American Independent Business Alliance from the Civic Economics study series puts the average at 52.9 percent recirculated locally for independents, against 13.6 percent for chains, roughly a four-to-one difference.

The measure of how much of a dollar spent at a business circulates again within the same local economy. It has three parts: what the business spends locally to operate, what it spends at other local businesses, and what its owners and employees spend of their income.

Structurally, yes, when the store sells imported inventory. In a commission the largest component is labor performed locally, whereas a retailer's imported cost of goods leaves the region immediately.

No. It is an average across retail studies conducted by Civic Economics across multiple markets and categories. Custom furniture making was not the study subject. The direction of the finding applies; the precise number should be read as a general ratio.

They are different questions. Local addresses where the money circulates and whether you can visit and be repaired. American-made addresses supply chain, materials regulation, and tariffs. A commission from a maker in your region satisfies both. See our piece on buying American-made furniture.
    How much money stays local when you buy from a local maker | Maker Marketplace